Skip to content

25 March, 2023

Subscribe Advertise About Us
  • My Account
  • Register
  • Log In
  • Log Out

Board Agenda

  • Governance
  • Strategy
  • Risk
  • Ethics
  • News
    • Categories

      • View All
      • Board Moves
    • Mars ESG

      News round-up: this week in governance

      Mars CEO defends ESG and purpose; US president vetoes anti-ESG bill; trust can negatively affect...

    • ChatGPT technology Could ChatGPT technology join the board?

      Although governance may stop artificial intelligence replacing anyone on the board today, AI may soon...

    • ethical decision-making Call for FTSE 100 companies to give guidance on ethics

      Most top firms have a published code of ethics, but many lack the framework to...

  • Insight
    • Categories

      • View all
      • Governance
      • Strategy
      • Risk
      • Ethics
      • Board Expertise
      • finance
      • Technology
    • data decision

      How to boost decision making

      Innovative digital tools can help boards to deliver against strategic objectives, but it is the...

    • remote working

      Navigating the new world of work

      Firms need to focus on building an inclusive environment and a culture of trust to...

    • digital transformation

      Digital transformation: Get the basics right

      Board involvement at the get-go will boost the chances of a successful digital transformation for...

  • Comment
      • View all
    • uncertainty in 2023

      Being a CEO in 2023: how to navigate uncertainty

      Agility, planning in the shorter term and bravery will all stand chief executives in good...

    • A week of business moving to the centre of human rights

      A week of events signals the initiatives underway to have companies play a central role...

    • audit reform IIA Why we need audit reform right now

      There is an "urgent need" for reform to the audit landscape as well as internal...

  • Interviews
      • View All Interviews
      • Podcasts
      • Webinars
    • life sciences podcast Reform of NHS levy ‘harms UK competitiveness’

      Boards in the pharmaceutical and life sciences sector face increasingly difficult decisions, according to a...

    • Board priorities 2023 Board priorities 2023: tact, trust and transparency

      We asked key figures what would help boards this year. The answers ranged from 'smarter...

    • Group of investors/shareholders in glass building Climate issues likely to figure prominently at next year’s AGMs

      A recent webinar heard that say-on-climate voting is expected to rise, while ESG remains a...

  • Careers
      • View all
      • Selection
      • Board Moves
    • female ceo Less than a third of FTSE 100 executives are women

      In Europe as a whole, only 7.7% of top companies’ chief executives are female, gender...

    • board size Performance declines as boards grow in size

      Researchers found that investment dropped by 2-3 percentage points as companies passed from 12 to...

    • Silicon Valley governance Silicon Valley improves its governance

      Big technology companies are stealing a march over other top corporates when it comes to...

  • Resource Centre
      • White Paper Downloads
      • Book Reviews
      • Corporate & Advisory Services
    • Diligent report

      Forrester: The Total Economic Impact Of Diligent Board & Leadership Collaboration

      Diligent Board Leadership & Collaboration reduced the risk of confidential material loss, supported decision-making, and...

    • Gender diversity barometer

      Barometer of Gender Diversity in Governing Bodies in Europe

      The 2023 Barometer of Gender Diversity in Governing Bodies in Europe looks at the 16...

    • geopolitical risk airmic

      Navigating geopolitical risk

      Today, the future feels less secure, and optimism is more restrained. Taking decisions in an...

  • Events
  • Search by topic
    • Governance
    • Strategy
    • Risk
    • Ethics
    • Regulation
    • ESG
    • Investor Relations
    • Selection
    • Board Expertise
    • finance
    • Technology

Threat to stakeholder governance from Twitter sale ‘overstated’

by Gavin Hinks on January 27, 2023

Academics and experts argue stakeholder governance will always come second while the law puts the interests of shareholders first.

stakeholder governance

Image: MichaelVi/Shutterstock.com

Last year, one of the most renowned US business academics and his team argued that the sale of Twitter sounded a death knell for “stakeholder governance”. Experts from around the world have now considered the claim, concluding that the sale of the world’s most influential social media companies “overstates” the implications for a concept that has come to dominate governance debate.

In a 24-page paper posted this week, Lucian Bebchuk, a Harvard professor, and his team repeated their claim that the sale of Twitter “pushed stakeholders under the bus”. Many Twitter staff were quickly made redundant, some with very little severance pay.

“Our analysis supports the view that the stakeholder rhetoric of corporate leaders, including in corporate mission and purpose statements, is mostly for show and is not matched by their actual decisions and conduct,” writes the Bebchuk group.

They add that corporates can also not be trusted to “safeguard” the interests of stakeholders in the event of a takeover.

The stakeholder message is one that Bebchuk has pursued since 2018, when the Business Roundtable, a club for leaders of the largest US companies, shocked the corporate world by publishing a statement claiming its members were now all “stakeholder companies”.

Despite his record, Bebchuk and co’s claims for Twitter have fallen flat in many circles.

According to Suren Gomtsian, a business law professor at Leeds University, the Twitter sale is limited evidence for a problem with stakeholder governance.

“Examples like Twitter do not tell us anything about the effectiveness of pro-stakeholder rhetoric and mission, and purpose, statements during normal times.

“All that such examples show is that the pro-stakeholder rhetoric gets overlooked during corporate acquisitions.”

A going concern

Gomtsian argues there are two structural reasons why stakeholders may be forgotten by boards at takeover time. Firstly, it’s the end of the road for boards; if they sell, then stakeholder concerns are “the problem of the new owner, not selling managers”.

Second, and perhaps more significantly, legal structures may not compel a board to consider stakeholders—the Twitter board had no option but to consider only shareholders once they were clear that their only option was to sell.

Richard Leblanc, governance professor at York University in Toronto, and author of The Handbook of Board Governance, echoes the point. He notes the Twitter board faced no “constituency statute” under Californian law that mandated consideration of stakeholder interests.

That said, Leblanc adds that investors in many jurisdictions are, nevertheless, placing boards under pressure to consider stakeholders as they come to accept that “customers, employees, suppliers, communities” are the “engines for shareholder value”.

“We will see where Twitter ends up,” says Leblanc. “It is a work in progress—a grand experiment—and we should exercise care in extrapolating any premature lessons.”

Better by design

Companies can choose to embrace stakeholders. Marco Meyer, a corporate ethics expert at the University of Hamburg and a director at Principia Advisory, an ethics consultancy, says both outdoor clothing brand Patagonia and OpenAI, a San Francisco-based artificial intelligence company, have set up governance structures to “explicitly” protect stakeholder interests. “Corporate governance needs to be designed with the ethical purpose of corporates in mind,” Meyer says.

In the UK, a campaign is under way to reform the law—the Companies Act—to ensure directors’ duties reflect stakeholders’ interests.

According to Roger Barker, policy director at the Institute of Directors and a supporter of reform: “A more balanced stakeholder approach will only move from rhetoric to reality when the privileged position of shareholders in company law is addressed.

“That’s the thinking behind the Better Business Act campaign in the UK—to change the underlying nature of directors’ fiduciary duties so that shareholders aren’t prioritised at the expense of everyone else.”

There are those, however, who believe the shareholder versus stakeholder row is redundant. Mark Goyder, co-author of the book Entrusted: Stewardship for Responsible Wealth Creation, argues that directors owe a duty to neither group, but to the company.

Takeovers raise a special question about directors’ duties. He cites the Kraft acquisition of Cadbury in 2010 as an example of where a board could have turned its back on an offer because the “decision was not exclusively about maximising the price they might get”.

Likewise the Twitter sale, because its “duty was to the company and through that to those with whom the company had long-term relationships, especially the employees”, adds Goyder.

Whatever the situation at Twitter, the stakeholder debate and what it means in practice will rumble on. In many jurisdictions, the concept is already well entrenched in governance thinking and that means the discourse on governance may well have changed for good. Stakeholderism may have taken a blow, but it’s far from dead.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Mail

Related Posts

  • Twitter's sale to Elon Musk leaves stakeholder governance high and dry
    November 16, 2022
    Twitter stakeholders

    The company’s failure to consider in advance those affected by the deal does not bode well for stakeholder governance, write academics.

  • Twitter drops due diligence bombshell
    August 11, 2022
    Twitter Elon Musk

    The high-profile lawsuit brought by Twitter against Elon Musk raises an issue close to all board members’ hearts.

  • Is Elon Musk trolling Twitter?
    April 12, 2022

    Tesla and SpaceX CEO Musk has created a tricky governance challenge by buying a 9.2% stake in Twitter but declining a seat on the board.

  • News round-up: this week in governance
    May 13, 2022
    Amanda Blanc, Aviva CEO

    Aviva CEO faces "inappropriate" remarks at shareholder meeting; warning for Twitter board over free speech; speaking up on whistleblowing.

For thoughtful journalism, expert insights on corporate governance and an extensive library of reports, guides and tools to help boards and directors navigate the complexities of their roles, subscribe to Board Agenda

Business Roundtable, Cadbury, Companies Act, corporate governance, Elon Musk, ESG, ethics, Institute of Directors, investors, Kraft, Lucian Bebchuk, M&As, Marco Meyer, Mark Goyder, news, OpenAI, Patagonia, Regulation, Richard Leblanc, Roger Barker, shareholder value, shareholders, stakeholder governance, stakeholders, Suren Gomtsian, Twitter

Search


Sign up to our Newsletter

Receive independent news, thoughtful journalism & expert insights about leadership, corporate governance & key boardroom issues straight to your inbox every week.

SIGN UP

Follow Us

 

 

 

 

Most Popular

  • Could ChatGPT technology join the board?
  • Larry Fink puts focus on finance and inflation
  • ESG resilience requires leaders to manage without certainty
  • Call for FTSE 100 companies to give guidance on ethics
  • Into the mind of white-collar criminals

Featured Partner Profile

Diligent

Diligent

Diligent Corporation, which was founded in 2001, is headquartered in New York, NY with a European HQ in London. Diligent’s modern governance platform empowers leaders and teams at every level of the organisation to digitally transform and create ...

Featured Partner Resources

2022 AGM Season Forecast: An Eye on The Horizon

To help prepare for AGMs in 2022, Equiniti (EQ) hi...

Stakeholder Engagement: A Roadmap for UK Plc Boards

This guide aims to provide directors and their col...

Digital Boards: How Technology Adoption is Driving Culture Change and Resiliency

Digital tools proved their worth to boards during ...
Leadership in AI report

Leadership in AI

This report from Board Agenda and Mazars, in assoc...
Creativity in a Crisis: a Boardroom Map for Innovation

Creativity in a Crisis: a Boardroom Map for Innovation

In the uncertain times at the height of any crisis...
Board Directors Guide to D&O Liability Insurance - November 2020 - AIG & Board Agenda

Board Directors' Guide to D&O Liability Insurance

Directors face liability over a range of new threa...
Leadership-in-Risk-Management-Board-Report

Leadership in Risk Management: Board Report

Board Agenda, in association with Mazars and INSEA...
Director's Guide to Internal Investigations

A Director's Guide to Conducting Internal Investigations

An internal investigation must be handled meticulo...

 


 

ADVERTISE – FREE CORPORATE LISTING

FREE - Add your company profile to our Corporate & Advisory Directory.
ADD

ADVERTISE – PROMOTE YOUR REPORTS & WHITEPAPERS

FREE - Add your company profile to our Corporate & Advisory Directory.
Add Resource

Register Free

Register to receive free article views, selected resource downloads, and all the latest news alerts straight to your inbox. Register


  • Editors & Contributors
  • Editorial Advisory Board
  • Corporate & Advisory Services
  • Media Marketing Solutions
  • Contact Us
  • Careers
  • Board Director Network
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies
  • Sitemap
|