Skip to content

1 December, 2023

Subscribe Advertise About Us
  • My Account
  • Register
  • Log In
  • Log Out

Board Agenda

  • Governance
  • Strategy
  • Risk
  • Ethics
  • News
    • Categories

      • View All
      • Board Moves
    • Proxy adviser warns LSE

      Proxy adviser warns LSE over governance

      Abolishing the public register of shareholder revolts ‘won’t stop capital providers exercising their democratic rights’,...

    • sustainability governance Sustainability governance is on the rise

      But despite greater corporate attention being paid to ESG, directors’ engagement with it is losing...

    • Sam Altman News round-up: this week in governance

      OpenAI fires and rehires Sam Altman; is it OK for the Big Four to remain...

  • Insight
    • Categories

      • View all
      • Governance
      • Strategy
      • Risk
      • Ethics
      • Board Expertise
      • finance
      • Technology
    • purpose statement

      On purpose: crafting an authentic statement

      Purpose statements define how organisations align purpose and people. Here’s how to make a statement...

    • first-time CFO

      How to succeed as a first-time CFO

      The remit and responsibilities of the chief financial officer have changed, which can seem daunting...

    • ethical culture

      How to embed an ethical culture

      Business success depends on purpose—and therefore ethics—being the top item on any organisation’s board agenda.

  • Comment
      • View all
    • uk corporate governance

      Why UK corporate governance needs tightening up

      The LSE’s response to the government’s panicky U-turn on governance regulation is not helpful to...

    • faith in the UK Audit reform is essential to restore faith in the UK

      When it comes to understanding what attracts investors to a capital market, the London Stock...

    • U-turn on audit reform An uncomfortable U-turn on audit reform

      The government’s bonfire of the regulations expected for audit reform creates a source of uncertainty...

  • Interviews
      • View All Interviews
      • Podcasts
      • Webinars
    • reporting elements Boards urged to retain ‘beneficial’ reporting elements

      Although the government cancelled the requirement, resilience disclosures ‘cannot be wasted effort’, says senior auditco...

    • energy transition Collaboration is key to UK energy transition

      Communication, innovation and engagement are needed for the move to net zero, an expert panel...

    • helle bank jorgensen Helle Bank Jørgensen on governance, ESG and how board directors can become stewards of the future

      In spite of ESG toxicity in the US, she remains optimistic that companies are working...

  • Careers
      • View all
      • Selection
      • Board Moves
    • gender diversity study Academics criticise BlackRock gender diversity research

      Its methodology came under fire, with some critics also pointing out it was wrong to...

    • diversity of thought How to boost diversity of thought

      Companies benefit from diverse workforces, but also from having the input of different opinions and...

    • minority NED Number of minority NEDs drops

      Although there is some progress in diversity in other board roles, research suggests that boards...

  • Resource Centre
      • White Paper Downloads
      • Book Reviews
      • Corporate & Advisory Services
    • Risk Map: Top Risks 2024

      Control Risks' Top Risks for 2024 cut across the geopolitical, security, operational, regulatory, and cyber/digital...

    • A Director’s Guide to Conducting Internal Investigations 2023

      An internal investigation must be handled meticulously to avoid legal exposure, regulatory or criminal prosecution...

    • Spencer Stuart UK Board Index Highlights 2023 cover

      Spencer Stuart UK Board Index Highlights 2023

      The 2023 UK Spencer Stuart Board Index is a review of board composition and governance...

  • Events
  • Search by topic
    • Governance
    • Strategy
    • Risk
    • Ethics
    • Regulation
    • ESG
    • Investor Relations
    • Selection
    • Board Expertise
    • finance
    • Technology

Business Roundtable stakeholder statement ‘mostly for show’, says study

by Gavin Hinks on August 25, 2021

Harvard researchers say signatories have made few changes in company documents that indicate a corporate purpose favouring stakeholders.

Jamie Dimon

Business Roundtable chair and JP Morgan CEO Jamie Dimon at the Fortune Global Forum. Image by Fortune Live Media, licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

Since the Business Roundtable, a club for chief executives at some of the most high-profile companies in the US, announced in 2019 that it was in favour of prioritising stakeholders over shareholders, there has been much talk about the nature of big business changing.

But a close of examination by academics of the companies involved reveals not much has changed. Indeed, the statement, the researchers say, seems to have been “for show” and served to head off government intervention.

After reviewing documents from more than 130 companies signed up to the Business Roundtable’s (BRT) Statement of the Purpose of the Corporation, Lucian Bebchuk and Roberto Tallarita of Harvard Law School, find that companies such as JPMorgan Chase, Apple, Amazon and Pfizer—among others—have made no changes in company statements that indicate a corporate purpose favouring stakeholders.

In a commentary the authors write: “Overall our findings support the view that the BRT statement did not represent a meaningful commitment and was not planned or expected to bring about meaningful improvements in the treatment of stakeholders.”

The “main impact” they say may be to “insulate” corporate leaders from shareholders and to head off potential action from politicians and regulators.

And there is a grim conclusion. “Reliance on the discretion of corporate leaders to serve stakeholders, as supporters of stakeholder governance advocate, would be an ineffective and counterproductive approach to the protection of stakeholders.”

Company documents

When Bebchuk and Tallarita looked at the companies of Roundtable board members at the time of the statement, 68% made no mention of stakeholders in documents at the end of 2020. At JPMorgan Chase, whose chief executive Jamie Dimon was chair of the Roundtable at the time of the statement, company guidelines say: “The Board as a whole is responsible for the oversight of management on behalf of the Firm’s shareholders.”

The researchers also examined documents at 25 “large” company members of the Roundtable that signed up to the statement. A total of 84% made no mention of stakeholders in their documents and 73% “explicitly embraced shareholder primacy”. Of 86 further members of the Roundtable, 76% ignored stakeholders in company statements of purpose; 57% made explicit commitments to shareholders.

In fact, Bebchuk and Tallarita could find only two companies they could classify as “stakeholder” organisations, Cummins and International Paper. And for these companies, the 2019 declarations represented no change on previous commitments.

Overall the investigators made a number of observations about Roundtable members. Language in corporate guidelines generally did not improve the status of stakeholders, while most reflected a shareholder primacy. Following 40 shareholder proposals demanding implementation of the Roundtable statement, the companies involved refused to recognise any need for change.

Bebchuk and Tallarita conclude support for the 2019 statement was “mostly for show” and Roundtable members “did not intend or expect it to bring about any material change in how they treat stakeholders”.

That may leave some wondering what gains have been made despite widespread discussion of stakeholderism. Indeed, there appears to be reassessment under way looking at corporate commitments to stakeholderism, corporate purpose and sustainability. In the UK at least, some campaigners are demanding changes to the law to beef up boardroom responsibilities to a wider group of stakeholders.

The pandemic has increased pressure for corporates to regard stakeholders with the same importance as shareholders. As the full implications of the crisis continue to unravel, stakeholderism is bound to remain a key point of debate.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Mail

Related Posts

  • Business Roundtable takes aim at SEC climate risk reporting
    July 14, 2022
    Tim Cook, Apple

    Among its complaints, the Business Roundtable argues that no ‘safe harbor’ in the rules will increase the risk of corporate liability.

  • Business transformation is a priority now, say experts
    August 15, 2022
    business transformation

    As business survival depends on adapting to the changing post-pandemic economic landscape, it's as well to be ahead of the game.

  • Investors influence ESG performance, study reveals
    July 26, 2022
    Investors influence ESG

    Researchers find that, among the many drivers for improving ESG, intervention by corporate investors is key.

  • ESG reporting all-important in stakeholder engagement
    July 7, 2022
    stocks, asset management, shares, investor engagement

    Experts advise that by boosting their annual reporting, boards can build trust and form more meaningful relationships with investors.

For thoughtful journalism, expert insights on corporate governance and an extensive library of reports, guides and tools to help boards and directors navigate the complexities of their roles, subscribe to Board Agenda

Business Roundtable, corporate purpose, research, stakeholder capitalism, stakeholders, strategy

Search


Sign up to our Newsletter

Receive independent news, thoughtful journalism & expert insights about leadership, corporate governance & key boardroom issues straight to your inbox every week.

SIGN UP

Follow Us





Most Popular

  • Why UK corporate governance needs tightening up
  • How to succeed as a first-time CFO
  • How to embed an ethical culture
  • Director Reference Guide: board governance and leadership on data
  • On purpose: crafting an authentic statement

Featured Partner Profile

Diligent

Diligent

Diligent Corporation, which was founded in 2001, is headquartered in New York, NY with a European HQ in London. Diligent’s modern governance platform empowers leaders and teams at every level of the organisation to digitally transform and create ...

Featured Partner Resources

Leadership ESG

Leadership in ESG Integration: a study into UK board oversight, implementation and disclosure

This research report is based on detailed response...
The Engagement Appeal: The Path to Inclusive Investor Engagement

The Engagement Appeal: The Path to Inclusive Investor Engagement

This is the inaugural white paper from The Engagem...
Mazars c-suite 2023

Mazars C-suite barometer 2023

The Mazars C-suite barometer is based on responses...

Stakeholder Engagement: A Roadmap for UK Plc Boards

This guide aims to provide directors and their col...

Digital Boards: How Technology Adoption is Driving Culture Change and Resiliency

Digital tools proved their worth to boards during ...
Leadership in AI report

Leadership in AI

This report from Board Agenda and Mazars, in assoc...

A Director's Guide to Conducting Internal Investigations 2023

An internal investigation must be handled meticulo...
 

ADVERTISE – FREE CORPORATE LISTING

FREE - Add your company profile to our Corporate & Advisory Directory.
ADD

ADVERTISE – PROMOTE YOUR REPORTS & WHITEPAPERS

FREE - Add your company profile to our Corporate & Advisory Directory.
Add Resource

Register Free

Register to receive free article views, selected resource downloads, and all the latest news alerts straight to your inbox. Register


  • Editors & Contributors
  • Editorial Advisory Board
  • Corporate & Advisory Services
  • Media Marketing Solutions
  • Contact Us
  • Careers
  • Board Director Network
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies
  • Sitemap
|

Copyright © 2023 Questor Media Group Ltd.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap