Skip to content

27 January, 2023

Subscribe Advertise About Us
  • My Account
  • Register
  • Log In
  • Log Out

Board Agenda

  • Governance
  • Strategy
  • Risk
  • Ethics
  • News
    • Categories

      • View All
      • Board Moves
    • Davos resilience

      News round-up: this week in governance

      Lessons from Davos; companies risk sliding back on ethical practices; economics affects everyone; Sir John...

    • audit reform UK Audit reform in the UK risks ‘losing momentum’

      The Financial Reporting Council still awaits the proposed new statutory powers that would allow it...

    • Elon Musk Glass Lewis Elon Musk weighs in against ISS and Glass Lewis

      On Twitter, Musk complains that large proxy advisers hold ‘far too much power’ over shareholder...

  • Insight
    • Categories

      • View all
      • Governance
      • Strategy
      • Risk
      • Ethics
      • Board Expertise
      • finance
      • Technology
    • climate litigation

      Climate litigation: how 2022 will shape 2023

      This past year saw a rise in climate litigation, with a focus on the commercial...

    • value whistleblowing

      Why we need to value whistleblowing

      Encouraging staff to speak up and stop harm can reduce legal and reputational risk—both for...

    • HR corporate trust

      HR: How to build employee trust in corporate culture

      The right HR director is essential to lead on a culture that gets the best...

  • Comment
      • View all
    • A week of business moving to the centre of human rights

      A week of events signals the initiatives underway to have companies play a central role...

    • audit reform IIA Why we need audit reform right now

      There is an "urgent need" for reform to the audit landscape as well as internal...

    • climate change energy crisis Sustainability and climate change: the other energy crisis

      The world is addicted to cheap energy. We need to admit this and have the...

  • Interviews
      • View All Interviews
      • Podcasts
      • Webinars
    • Board priorities 2023 Board priorities 2023: tact, trust and transparency

      We asked key figures what would help boards this year. The answers ranged from 'smarter...

    • Group of investors/shareholders in glass building Climate issues likely to figure prominently at next year’s AGMs

      A recent webinar heard that say-on-climate voting is expected to rise, while ESG remains a...

    • NEDs role NEDs ‘needed more than ever’ in times of uncertainty

      The non-executive director’s role is to both challenge and listen to management, agreed the panel...

  • Careers
      • View all
      • Selection
      • Board Moves
    • NED recruitment News round-up: this week in governance

      Your country needs NEDs; governance does not compute; financial firms get more women on board;...

    • HR corporate trust HR: How to build employee trust in corporate culture

      The right HR director is essential to lead on a culture that gets the best...

    • powerful CEOs Boards want powerful CEOs in tough times

      Single-minded chief executives have greater staying ability when business conditions are uncertain, research finds

  • Resource Centre
      • White Paper Downloads
      • Book Reviews
      • Corporate & Advisory Services
    • Edelman Trust Barometer 2023

      2023 Edelman Trust Barometer

      The report is the result of the Edelman Trust Institute's research, which sampled more than...

    • Sophos 2023 Threat Report

      Barriers to entry for would-be cybercriminals are lower, with tools and tactics becoming available to...

    • The C-Suite Outlook 2023: On the Edge

      The Conference Board 2023 C-Suite Outlook survey reveals the events that C-suite executives see as...

  • Events
  • Search by topic
    • Governance
    • Strategy
    • Risk
    • Ethics
    • Regulation
    • ESG
    • Investor Relations
    • Selection
    • Board Expertise
    • finance
    • Technology

Audit committees face public reprimand as part of market reforms

by Gavin Hinks on April 18, 2019

The Competition and Markets Authority says regulators should punish audit committees, impose joint audits and force an “operational separation” of auditors from other parts of their firms
.

Big Four, Deloitte, KPMG, EY, PwC

Images: Shutterstock.com

Audit committees should face public reprimand by regulators if they fail to provide adequate scrutiny of their auditors, according to recommendations from the UK’s competition authority.

The proposal comes as part of a suite of measures published today by the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), which also includes mandatory joint audits and the operational separation of audit firms from other services, such as consultancy.

Part of a long-running probe of audit firms, the report is the result of public and political concerns following high-profile corporate collapses such as high street department store BHS and construction giant Carillion, among others.

In October the CMA began looking at the audit market and delivered an initial report in December. This week’s final report, urging the splitting of firms and joint audit, delivers recommendations that have, in the past, proved contentious with the big audit firms.

The CMA’s chair, Andrew Tyrie, said the government now had a number of reports that had broadly concluded the same thing: conflicts of interest affecting auditors had to be tackled and, with just four big firms serving the UK’s biggest companies, there are too few in the market.

“People’s livelihoods, savings and pensions all depend on the auditors’ job being done to a high standard,” said Tyrie. “But too many fall short—more than a quarter of big company audits are considered sub-standard by the regulator. This cannot be allowed to continue.”

Andrea Coscelli, the CMA’s chief executive, said the recommended changes would bolster UK corporate governance.
 “Our recommendations, along with improvements to regulation and clarifying the purpose and scope of audits, will ensure the UK strengthens its position,” Coscelli said.

“More than a quarter of big company audits are considered sub-standard by the regulator. This cannot be allowed to continue”

—Andrew Tyrie, CMA chair

Not everyone is impressed with the CMA’s report. The CBI, the UK’s biggest employer body, insisted some of the CMA’s proposals risk “damaging” the UK’s hard-won reputation for governance.

John Allan, CBI president, lauded greater scrutiny of audit committees but honed in on joint audits and operational separation.
 “Improving the quality of audit to enhance public trust and investor confidence must be paramount. But the guiding star for any reforms must be a focus on what works.

“Mandating joint audits will add cost and complexity for business with no guarantee of better outcomes. Operational splits could restrict access to the skills required to carry out complex audits.”

Some of the big firms meanwhile have been more measured in their response. PwC, the dominant auditor of large companies in the UK, issued a statement saying it recognised the “importance of increasing trust in audit and the consistency of audit quality”.
 The firm said: “It’s important that the potential impact and implementation of recommendations are well thought through to ensure they deliver the desired outcomes and avoid any unintended consequences.”

That theme was picked up more forcefully by Stephen Griggs, Deloitte’s UK head of audit, who also re-emphasised the firm’s support for reform and the CMA’s “objective”.
 However, Griggs warned that some of the recommendations would fail to meet the needs for increased choice and competition, and could have “unintended consequences, such as lower audit quality, damage to UK competitiveness, and weaker resilience of the sector”.

“Mandating joint audits will add cost and complexity for business with no guarantee of better outcomes. Operational splits could restrict access to the skills required to carry out complex audits”

—John Allan, CBI president

Firms outside the big four drew attention to measures that failed to make the CMA’s recommendation, such as a market cap. But they also saw opportunities.

Scott Knight, BDO’s UK head of audit, pointed to the significance of a CMA recommendation that companies could avoid a joint audit if they opted for a non-big-four, or “challenger”, audit firm.
“The exemption from joint audits if companies appoint a challenger firm is new and could have a major impact,” he said.

Others have pointed to yet more policies the CMA looked at but did not include. Paul Boyle, a former chief executive of the FRC, recently published a paper for the Centre for Study of Financial Innovation, recommending reform of the ownership rules governing audit firms. Currently, they can only be operated by “qualified” auditors. Boyle believes this should be liberalised.

Issues in the audit market

Joint audits and some form of separation have been long-running demands from some quarters for UK firms and, until now, always successfully countered by the big four, which argued they would do little to improve audit quality.

Earlier attempts have also been made to tackle issues in the audit market. Triggered by concerns that auditors failed to see the risks to financial institutions ahead of the financial crisis, the EU issued reforms in 2014. New laws introduced mandatory audit firm rotation, restrictions on alternative services that could be offered to audit clients and new responsibilities for audit committees.

The current audit crisis was sparked by the collapse of Carillion, though other corporate failures contributed to a widespread concern.
 At the root of concerns are three main claims.

First, auditors are too close to their clients because of the perceived need to sell additional services, such as consultancy or tax advice, and therefore lack independence. It is claimed this then affects the quality of audit.

Second, there is disagreement over the purpose audits serve. Some argue they can only be about checking processes; others insist they should be used to root out frauds or risky business models.

Lastly, and connected, is the claim that there are simply too few big audit firms to provide the level of competition needed to produce high quality, independent audits. The collapse of Arthur Andersen in 2002, following the Enron scandal, left just four big firms—PwC, KPMG, EY and Deloitte—servicing audits to 100% of the FTSE100 and 97% of the FTSE350.

Throughout 2018, MPs on parliamentary committees investigated the collapse of Carillion, including the roles of the company’s auditor and the audit regulator. 
In December Sir John Kingman published his review of the Financial Reporting Council, recommending its abolition and replacement with a new body to be called the Audit, Reporting and Governance Authority.

The government accepted the recommendations of the report, though when the new body will be up and running remains unclear.
 December also saw the government launch a review into audit quality and standards under the leadership of Donald Brydon, the outgoing chair of the London Stock Exchange. Brydon is expected to report by the end of the year.

The CMA’s recommendations will now have to be translated into legislation, which could be a lengthy process given that government and Parliament are preoccupied with Brexit. That could provide yet another opportunity to tussle over the detail.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Mail

Related Posts

  • Boards need dedicated ESG committees 'as part of company strategy'
    November 25, 2021
    Board members discussing ESG

    Report for the Institute of Directors says boards need to integrate ESG into strategy and operations as a response to climate concerns.

  • Audit committee chairs 'are confusing quality of audit and quality of service'
    February 2, 2022
    Calculator on top of business report

    FRC report also warns that audit committee chairs have a "negative perception of joint audits", despite this being a key reform proposal.

  • What the decline of General Electric can teach us about M&As
    December 17, 2021
    General Electric logo on a GE aviation facility in Cincinnati

    GE has been pursuing M&As for over 20 years—with disastrous outcomes. A closer look reveals obvious governance failures.

  • Kevin Davidson named as CEO of Norman Broadbent
    September 10, 2021
    Directors waiting for an interview

    Davidson was previously managing director of Ducatus Partners and chief executive of Maxwell Drummond International.

For thoughtful journalism, expert insights on corporate governance and an extensive library of reports, guides and tools to help boards and directors navigate the complexities of their roles, subscribe to Board Agenda

audit committee, Big Four, Carillion, Competition and Markets Authority, Deloitte, EY, KPMG, PwC

Search


Sign up to our Newsletter

Receive independent news, thoughtful journalism & expert insights about leadership, corporate governance & key boardroom issues straight to your inbox every week.

SIGN UP

Follow Us

 

 

 

 

Most Popular

  • Activist investor campaigns rise back up to pre-Covid levels
  • How to ensure stakeholders trust your sustainability reporting
  • Companies ‘will face growing climate litigation’
  • News round-up: this week in governance
  • Climate litigation: how 2022 will shape 2023
 

Featured Partner Profile

Diligent

Diligent

Diligent Corporation, which was founded in 2001, is headquartered in New York, NY with a European HQ in London. Diligent’s modern governance platform empowers leaders and teams at every level of the organisation to digitally transform and create ...

Featured Partner Resources

2022 AGM Season Forecast: An Eye on The Horizon

To help prepare for AGMs in 2022, Equiniti (EQ) hi...

Stakeholder Engagement: A Roadmap for UK Plc Boards

This guide aims to provide directors and their col...

Digital Boards: How Technology Adoption is Driving Culture Change and Resiliency

Digital tools proved their worth to boards during ...
Leadership in AI report

Leadership in AI

This report from Board Agenda and Mazars, in assoc...
Creativity in a Crisis: a Boardroom Map for Innovation

Creativity in a Crisis: a Boardroom Map for Innovation

In the uncertain times at the height of any crisis...
Board Directors Guide to D&O Liability Insurance - November 2020 - AIG & Board Agenda

Board Directors' Guide to D&O Liability Insurance

Directors face liability over a range of new threa...
Leadership-in-Risk-Management-Board-Report

Leadership in Risk Management: Board Report

Board Agenda, in association with Mazars and INSEA...
Director's Guide to Internal Investigations

A Director's Guide to Conducting Internal Investigations

An internal investigation must be handled meticulo...

 


 

ADVERTISE – FREE CORPORATE LISTING

FREE - Add your company profile to our Corporate & Advisory Directory.
ADD

ADVERTISE – PROMOTE YOUR REPORTS & WHITEPAPERS

FREE - Add your company profile to our Corporate & Advisory Directory.
Add Resource

Register Free

Register to receive free article views, selected resource downloads, and all the latest news alerts straight to your inbox. Register


  • Editors & Contributors
  • Editorial Advisory Board
  • Corporate & Advisory Services
  • Media Marketing Solutions
  • Contact Us
  • Careers
  • Board Director Network
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies
  • Sitemap
|