Skip to content

13 August, 2026

  • Saved Articles
  • My Account
  • Subscribe
  • Log In
  • Log Out

Board Agenda

  • Governance
  • Strategy
  • Risk
  • Ethics
  • News
  • Insight
    • Categories

      • View all
      • Governance
      • Strategy
      • Risk
      • Ethics
      • Board expertise
      • Finance
      • Technology
    • climate litigation

      Why climate transition is a governance imperative

      The ‘just transition’ to a sustainable, resilient economy means navigating systemic change fairly and successfully.

      board skills clash

      When board skills clash

      Board composition in terms of expertise has a clear impact on entrepreneurial decision-making and strategy,...

      create value

      4 ways to help your CFO create value

      The chief financial officer has a vital contribution to make to the board’s strategy on...

  • Comment
      • View all
    • climate litigation

      Why climate transition is a governance imperative

      The ‘just transition’ to a sustainable, resilient economy means navigating systemic change fairly and successfully.

      create value

      4 ways to help your CFO create value

      The chief financial officer has a vital contribution to make to the board’s strategy on...

      leadership crisis

      How to fix the leadership crisis

      Unpopular opinion? It’s time for organisations to shift away from feelings to focus on competency...

  • Interviews
      • View All Interviews
      • Podcasts
      • Webinars
    • governance

      How better governance helps private companies grow

      If governance is to become mature, management decision-making has no place on the board’s agenda,...

      future-ready

      Is your board ‘future-ready’?

      The survival of a business in uncertain times depends on its ability to pivot as...

      investor confidence

      Lack of audit reform ‘will hit investor confidence’

      Government's failure to push ahead with audit reform is a risk to UK investments, the...

  • Board Careers
      • View All
    • board skills clash

      When board skills clash

      Board composition in terms of expertise has a clear impact on entrepreneurial decision-making and strategy,...

      female ceos

      FTSE 100 CEO appointments rise

      The number of CEO appointments has doubled in six months, although the global picture suggests...

      board role

      How to engage with outreach

      When board opportunities knock, should you answer the door? Here are tips from a new...

  • Resource Centre
      • White Paper Downloads
      • Book Reviews
      • Board Advisory & Corporate Services
    • FRC Annual Review of Audit Quality 2026

      This Financial Reporting Council report uses findings from its supervisory activities to assess audit quality...

      Governance Guide: How Boards Drive Growth

      This Board Agenda Governance Guide investigates how directors can evolve to drive performance and growth...

      Organizational Transformation in the Age of AI

      This World Economic Forum paper looks at how organisations must re-architect their workflows and operating...

  • Events
  • Search by topic
    • Governance
    • Strategy
    • Risk
    • Ethics
    • Regulation
    • ESG
    • Investor Relations
    • Careers
    • Board Expertise
    • finance
    • Technology

Sir Roger Carr: What makes a good non-executive?

by Gavin Hinks on March 29, 2019

Board Agenda was at the Non-Executive Director Awards in London to see Sir Roger Carr—chair of BAE Systems and the English National Ballet, former chair of Cadbury and Centrica—receive the Lifetime Achievement Award. In his acceptance speech Sir Roger explored the qualities that make a good non-executive.

Sir Roger Carr

Sir Roger Carr (centre) with Sheryl Cuisia of Boudicca Proxy Consultants, and Oliver Shah, of the Sunday Times

Favorite

A lifetime achievement award has the thrill of a corporate Oscar—tinged with a slight sense of concern as a business obituary.

Nonetheless—having chaired these awards in the past, and seen previous winners—I receive this award with a mix of enormous gratitude and considerable humility. So, thank you very much.

In these turbulent times, the need for non-executives has never been greater. Having had the privilege of sitting on many boards, in good times and the not so good (of which there have been a few) I am often asked what I think makes for a good non-executive. So, I felt I would take this moment to share with you my top five.

First: Make sure you have the right motives when joining a board. The risk reward ratio is rarely favourable. The standard five principles of life: “What’s in it for me?”, must be outweighed by, “What can I contribute to it?”

To contribute you must have a genuine interest in the business, a desire to add value, a willingness to give advice, but the tolerance to be ignored.

And where you add value is critical: independent judgement on people; clarity of mind on risk management; vision for the future on strategy; focus on succession planning, and help in the day to day.

In summary, rule one, you need the skillset to contribute as an individual, but the mindset of a team player.

Rule two: Don’t confuse helping with meddling. This is one of the greatest challenges, particularly for those used to executive roles.

To help, you have to understand the business. Read the papers, visit the sites, engage with management, listening more than transmitting, thinking more than doing, advising more than telling.

So remember, board members challenge, advise, and encourage. Executives execute; non-executives execute the executive if they continually fail. Role confusion is dangerous for everyone.

Rule three: Have the humility to believe that others have something to offer and the patience to judge if you are right.

Weighing the evidence is vital, listening and learning. Rushing to judgement is risky, just as delay in acting on poor performance is dangerous. The best boards comprise individuals who are sure of themselves, but respect colleagues for their contribution; who are measured in forming opinions, but swift in implementing conclusions. A good principle—action this day—having slept on it overnight.

Rule four: Remember that you may have been hired for your experience but you will be valued most for your character.

As a chairman I look for those who are authentic in manner: who look to the mirror for judgement not the gallery for applause; who have the courage to speak truth to power and the resilience to be rebuffed.

Most importantly the integrity to know—whatever the pressure from shareholders, competitors, customers or peers—a board must do the right thing simply because it is the right thing to do.

Finally, rule five: Remember shareholders, employees, prospective employees and customers increasingly focus on how you make money, not simply how much money you make.

Honesty, integrity and diversity are the hallmarks of a good board. And diversity is not box ticking. It provides the healthiest environment for collective decision making, it is a combination of merit and gender. We have made good progress in the boardroom, it is work in progress in executive management, and we have a long way to go to see more women in the role of chair.

Let’s not forget this is not simply a gender issue, it’s about making business better. Plus respect for the environment, concern for all stakeholders.

These are not optional extras. They are at the heart of the business and the key to social acceptability. If capitalism is to thrive, the reputation of business must improve and in this, the role of the non-executive is key; how we conduct ourselves, present ourselves, govern ourselves and pay ourselves.

In short business and business leaders must be performance driven, value led. Being a non-executive is not simply a job, it is a privilege  and vital if business is to be of value to society and valued by the community in which we live. Thank you.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Mail

Related Posts

  • NED Awards 2022: a diverse range of nominees and outstanding winners
    March 28, 2022
    NED Awards

    This year's winners include a hospital foundation chair, a diversity leader and a chair at the heart of efforts on a Covid vaccine.

  • Tate & Lyle appoints Jeff Carr as non-executive director
    March 7, 2024
    tate NED

    Reckitt Benckiser CFO Jeff Carr will sit on the food company’s board as a non-executive director from next month.

  • Alan Ralph joins DCC board as non-executive director
    November 17, 2021
    DCC website close-up

    Ralph, a charted accountant and former chief financial officer at UDG Healthcare, has also been appointed to DCC's audit committee.

  • Alan Keir joins Nationwide board as non-executive director
    March 14, 2022
    Nationwide Building Society

    Keir is a former group managing director and CEO EMEA at HSBC, and is expected to chair Nationwide's board risk committee from July.

Search


Follow Us

Most Popular

Featured Resources

The Future of FTSE 350 Chairs: Pathways, Pipelines & Barriers 2026

This report is a collaboration between the FTSE Women Leaders Review and Professor...

Agentic AI from principles to practice 

‘A C-suite guide to capturing value without losing control’, this Forvis Mazars...

Route to the Top: Europe 2026 

This survey report from Heidrick & Struggles finds that companies are tending...
board's role in a rewired world fgs 2026 cover

A hard job getting harder: The board's role in a rewired world

The role of a corporate director is demanding intellectually, ethically and strategically—and...

Boardroom resilience: Practical governance for risk, readiness and rapid response

Boards are operating in a world defined by uncertainty. Geopolitical tensions, climate...

Board Value Index Summer 2026

Board Intelligence found 86% of directors say rigid processes and inconsistent frameworks...

Governance Guide: Navigating Conflict in the Boardroom

The 'Governance Guide' on navigating conflict in the boardroom provides practical...

Becoming a non-executive director (4th edition)

Board composition is the subject of much debate, while the role of the non-executive...

SUBSCRIBE TODAY

Stay current with a wide-ranging source of governance news and intelligence and apply the latest thinking to your boardroom challenges. Subscribe


  • Editors & Contributors
  • Editorial Advisory Board
  • Board Advisory & Corporate Services
  • Media Marketing Solutions
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Board Director Network
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies

Copyright © 2026 Questor Media Group Ltd.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy