Skip to content

10 August, 2026

  • Saved Articles
  • My Account
  • Subscribe
  • Log In
  • Log Out

Board Agenda

  • Governance
  • Strategy
  • Risk
  • Ethics
  • News
  • Insight
    • Categories

      • View all
      • Governance
      • Strategy
      • Risk
      • Ethics
      • Board expertise
      • Finance
      • Technology
    • create value

      4 ways to help your CFO create value

      The chief financial officer has a vital contribution to make to the board’s strategy on...

      leadership crisis

      How to fix the leadership crisis

      Unpopular opinion? It’s time for organisations to shift away from feelings to focus on competency...

      AI behaviour

      How do you measure AI adoption?

      It’s easy to produce metrics on AI software deployment, but these are pointless without tracking...

  • Comment
      • View all
    • create value

      4 ways to help your CFO create value

      The chief financial officer has a vital contribution to make to the board’s strategy on...

      leadership crisis

      How to fix the leadership crisis

      Unpopular opinion? It’s time for organisations to shift away from feelings to focus on competency...

      AI behaviour

      How do you measure AI adoption?

      It’s easy to produce metrics on AI software deployment, but these are pointless without tracking...

  • Interviews
      • View All Interviews
      • Podcasts
      • Webinars
    • governance

      How better governance helps private companies grow

      If governance is to become mature, management decision-making has no place on the board’s agenda,...

      future-ready

      Is your board ‘future-ready’?

      The survival of a business in uncertain times depends on its ability to pivot as...

      investor confidence

      Lack of audit reform ‘will hit investor confidence’

      Government's failure to push ahead with audit reform is a risk to UK investments, the...

  • Board Careers
      • View All
    • female ceos

      FTSE 100 CEO appointments rise

      The number of CEO appointments has doubled in six months, although the global picture suggests...

      board role

      How to engage with outreach

      When board opportunities knock, should you answer the door? Here are tips from a new...

      growth

      Governance Guide: How boards drive growth

      The strategic role of the board is changing rapidly, in line with a shifting world....

  • Resource Centre
      • White Paper Downloads
      • Book Reviews
      • Board Advisory & Corporate Services
    • FRC Annual Review of Audit Quality 2026

      This Financial Reporting Council report uses findings from its supervisory activities to assess audit quality...

      Governance Guide: How Boards Drive Growth

      This Board Agenda Governance Guide investigates how directors can evolve to drive performance and growth...

      Organizational Transformation in the Age of AI

      This World Economic Forum paper looks at how organisations must re-architect their workflows and operating...

  • Events
  • Search by topic
    • Governance
    • Strategy
    • Risk
    • Ethics
    • Regulation
    • ESG
    • Investor Relations
    • Careers
    • Board Expertise
    • finance
    • Technology

Spring brings shareholder pay revolt

by Gavin Hinks on May 17, 2016

Pay proposals have seen a raft of companies receive admonishment from shareholders through non-binding votes. But will companies act?

Favorite

no change there thenThe shareholders are revolting. That phrase may sound somewhat flippant but a quick survey of shareholder votes this spring reveals they are, indeed, up in arms over executive pay.

And though the votes may leave many weary with boredom—after all, we’ve been here before—this year’s rash of shareholder uprisings has a consistency and urgency about it that we may not have seen before.

Writing for The Telegraph, Ashley Hamilton Claxton, corporate governance manager for Royal London Asset Management, says: “Don’t get me wrong, we are not afraid to pay well for exceptional performance.

“But one cannot make decisions about executive pay in a social vacuum and it is hard to ignore or discount the growing concerns about pay inequality, particularly in light of recent lacklustre results.”

A string of big-name companies have been hit by shareholders objecting to boardroom pay packages.

Perhaps the most high-profile among these non-binding polls was the 59% against the pay of Bob Dudley, CEO of oil giant BP.

Bob Dudley. Photo: BP, Flickr
Bob Dudley. Photo: BP, Flickr

But there have been many others. A vote on remuneration at Smith & Nephew saw 53% against, Anglo American 42%, Shire 49% and, perhaps the biggest of them all, Weir Group, where shareholders pulled together a vote of 72% objecting to executive compensation proposals.

Hamilton Claxton says she has noted a number of  trends. The first is that higher pay has been sought even though company performance in 2015 was less than stellar. The reason: pay rises have been modest since the recession and executives are seen as “underpaid relative to peers”.

The second trend is “increasing scepticism” among City investors about pay models and whether they are “fit for purpose”.

Thirdly, there is “growing unease” at the rate at which boardroom pay is climbing compared with the average worker. She complains companies have used consultants to compose their remunerations policies which, while limiting salaries, has hefty cash top-ups for pensions.

Lastly, Hamilton Claxton notes that next year, unlike 2016, will see binding votes on remuneration packages. If 50% of shareholders votes against, remuneration committees will have to go back and start again.

She warns that while a 20% vote against pay was once viewed as shocking, polls of 30% or 40% are becoming the norm and the rhetoric of directors is starting to express this as a success.

Elsewhere, Patrick Jenkins in the Financial Times notes that the “madness’ of executive pay seemed to reach its peak with the package of Martin Winterkorn, the ousted boss of Volkswagen. It included a €5.9m “performance-related” award for 2015, the year in which VW’s value was severely damaged by the emissions scandal. Jenkins notes that investors are now starting to pay serious attention to the issue.

“If mainstream investors 
 press the issue, it will be unquestionably positive—for investor returns, of course, but also for society at large. It could help curb brewing scandals and fend off a nagging unease with the unfairness of capitalism.”

Clearly, the answer is greater involvement of shareholders, but this may be difficult given that their resources are spread over highly fragmented investment portfolios.

In April, boardrooms received a broadside from the Executive Remuneration Working Group, a collection of high-flying executives keen to see pay overhauled. The report called for reform of long-term bonus schemes and more transparency.

Legal & General’s chief executive, Nigel Wilson, worked on the report. He told the BBC: “The current approach to executive pay in UK listed companies is not fit for purpose, and has resulted in a poor alignment of interests between executives, shareholders and the company.

“Greater transparency, clearer alignment of shareholder, company and executive interests, more accountability on the part of remuneration committees and greater engagement with and control by shareholders, working through company boards, are vital to restore confidence in a system widely seen as broken.”

Clearly, the answer is greater involvement of shareholders, but this may be difficult given that their resources are spread over highly fragmented investment portfolios.

It’s worth bearing in mind the High Pay Centre report, published in April, which revealed that top pay was indeed still rising. Disclosures by 71 of the FTSE 100 showed that 40 reported higher single figures for 2015 than the sum for the previous year.

The centre’s director, Stefan Stern, said the UK’s disclosure rules meant that pay changes could be seen, “but the latent power possessed by investors to call a halt to these excessive rewards remains unexercised”.

However, 2017 will see a new element to question pay when the US introduces a mandatory requirement for most public companies to publish the ratio of CEO pay to that of employees.

On The Conversation website, Tobore Okah-Avae of Lancaster University writes that the publication of pay ratios will “likely help reduce pay inequality”.

He adds: “A mandatory rule requiring the publication of top-to-bottom pay ratios could 
 have two potential effects.

“It may force corporate boards to rethink excessive CEO pay and would hopefully force an increase in the pay offered to lower-level employees as well.”

 

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Mail

Related Posts

  • Europe sees 18% increase in shareholder revolts on executive pay
    September 7, 2021
    Businessman voting electronically

    Spain saw the greatest opposition to remuneration-related resolutions, with 60.6% contested—an increase of 33.2% year on year.

  • Boardroom pay revolts are on the rise as investors seek restraint
    July 2, 2021
    Coins in a pile

    Analysis by Board Agenda reveals that pay revolts in the first half of 2021 are up on the same period last year by 51%.

  • CEO pay falls by 9%—but LGIM issues warning over engagement
    November 22, 2021
    Businessman looking in his wallet

    PwC report shows executive pay has fallen; but LGIM says investor feedback on remuneration is being ignored.

  • Half of corporate leaders reject pay as a main driver for ESG
    June 28, 2022
    Executive pay and incentives

    Pay and incentives are ‘just one part’ of creating the right culture to boost ESG performance, survey finds.

Search


Follow Us

Most Popular

Featured Resources

The Future of FTSE 350 Chairs: Pathways, Pipelines & Barriers 2026

This report is a collaboration between the FTSE Women Leaders Review and Professor...

Agentic AI from principles to practice 

‘A C-suite guide to capturing value without losing control’, this Forvis Mazars...

Route to the Top: Europe 2026 

This survey report from Heidrick & Struggles finds that companies are tending...
board's role in a rewired world fgs 2026 cover

A hard job getting harder: The board's role in a rewired world

The role of a corporate director is demanding intellectually, ethically and strategically—and...

Boardroom resilience: Practical governance for risk, readiness and rapid response

Boards are operating in a world defined by uncertainty. Geopolitical tensions, climate...

Board Value Index Summer 2026

Board Intelligence found 86% of directors say rigid processes and inconsistent frameworks...

Governance Guide: Navigating Conflict in the Boardroom

The 'Governance Guide' on navigating conflict in the boardroom provides practical...

Becoming a non-executive director (4th edition)

Board composition is the subject of much debate, while the role of the non-executive...

SUBSCRIBE TODAY

Stay current with a wide-ranging source of governance news and intelligence and apply the latest thinking to your boardroom challenges. Subscribe


  • Editors & Contributors
  • Editorial Advisory Board
  • Board Advisory & Corporate Services
  • Media Marketing Solutions
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Board Director Network
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies

Copyright © 2026 Questor Media Group Ltd.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy